WI, Milwaukee
550 Sexual Abuse Claims Filed against Milwaukee
Archdiocese
About 550 people are asking for restitution for alleged sexual
abuse by clergy in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee - more than in
any of the other U.S. dioceses that have filed for bankruptcy
protection, according to a lawyer involved int eh Milwaukee case. One priest alone is accused of abusing some 200 boys at a
suburban school for deaf students from 1950 to 1974.
John Stang, a bankruptcy lawyer who represents creditors in the
Wisconsin case, estimated that about 550 claims had been filed by
the Wednesday afternoon deadline set by the bankruptcy court.
A victim’s advocacy group call the number of filings
“extraordinarily tragic”, but said that represented only a small
portion of people abused by clergy.
The other seven Catholic dioceses in the U.S. that have filed for
bankruptcy since the clergy abuse scandal erupted in 2002 in
Boston are in Davenport, Iowa; Fairbanks, Alaska; Portland, Ore;
San Diego, CA; Spokane, Wash.; Tucson, Ariz; and Wilmington,
Del. Two other religious order have also filed for bankruptcy.
1/13/2012:
Delaware Delaware’s Bradley Bills: Effective in raising voices to
stop child sexual abuse?
In December 2009, Delawareans were coming to grips with the arrest of former pediatrician Earl Bradley for sexually
molesting scores of young patients at his Lewes office. Delaware’s
response was quick. In 2010, legislators prepared a package of
bills—known collectively as the “Bradley bills”— designed to
strengthen patient protection and improve oversight of the
medical profession, passed those bills unanimously, and
Governor Jack Markell signed them into law in June of that
year. But in the year and a half since, how much of a difference
have the new laws made?
Two reviews were ordered following Bradley’s arrest—one by the
Attorney General’s office and another by Linda L. Ammons, dean
of Widener Law School. Both revealed systemic failures that
allowed Bradley to continue practicing despite numerous red flags
of misconduct raised by colleagues and family members.
The “Bradley bills” were designed to tighten regulations on
doctors and clarify the legal obligations of the medical and law
enforcement communities to report and share information
about suspected physician misconduct and child sexual abuse.
“These are sensitive cases and you need to approach them in a way
that offers opportunities for victims to come forward and to feel
they’re not going to run the risk of being re-victimized,” said Mike
Barlow, chief legal counsel in the Office of the Governor.
The new laws contain the following major provisions:
A requirement that there be another adult present when
the physician examines a disrobed patient aged 15 years
or younger;
A requirement that doctors, police and prosecutors
receive additional training in recognizing and reporting
child abuse;
A requirement that physicians undergo the same
background checks as teachers and other professionals
who work with youth;
A more robust reporting process enhanced by
strengthening the Board of Medical Licensure and
Discipline’s ability to police unprofessional conduct and
clarifying and simplifying its administrative procedures
to improve efficiency and its ability to work with law
enforcement.
Last year, the threat of license revocation for misconduct or
failure to report child sexual abuse was extended to include
mental health and chemical dependency professionals, nurses,
dentists, social workers, psychologists, dentists and dental
hygienists, and physician’s assistants. “One of the main
impacts of this package of legislation is to make sure that the
community, the state, caregivers, providers, doctors and
citizens know that they have a mandatory duty to report child
abuse and neglect when they see it to the state,” said Attorney
General Beau Biden.
Dean Ammons, who made 68 recommendations in her Bradley
case review, most of which were included in the legislation, agrees.
“You can’t legislate morals,” she said. “But what the state can do
is remove or attempt to remove barriers that make it complicated
or difficult for people to do the right thing.”
Indeed, experts commend Delaware for its ability to act swiftly and
decisively where other states have failed. “Pennsylvania is a good
example,” said Stephen J. Neuberger, attorney and partner in The
Neuberger Firm in Wilmington. “They had the grand jury report
(on the Archdiocese of Philadelphia) which just boggles the mind
and that didn’t get the legislature to do anything.”
Better educating the public about child sexual abuse will help
break the silence and taboo that surrounds child sexual abuse and
bolster the efforts made in the legislative arena. In September,
Biden announced a coordinated initiative to educate adults about
recognizing the signs of child abuse and their legal obligation to
report suspected crimes. The partnership, which includes Prevent
Child Abuse Delaware, the YMCA of Delaware as well as the
Attorney General’s office, aims to train 35,000 Delawareans or
about 5 percent of the population, in the “Steward of Children”
sexual abuse program.
“[Nationally], one out of four girls is sexually assaulted before
they’re 18,” said Biden. “One out of six boys is sexually assaulted
before they’re 18. Only one out of ten of these victims is ever able
to muster the courage to report because nine out of ten of the
perpetrators know or say they love or had the child entrusted to
them. So it should come as no surprise that children who don’t
have voices have a tough time raising their voice to report someone
who has raped or abused them. It’s not a child’s responsibility. It’s
our responsibility.”
1/12/2012:
MO, St. Louis
When federal investigators busted Jeffrey Greenwell
outside St. Louis, they hit the kiddie-porn jackpot
The child-pornography probe in Missouri that led to the arrest of
Jeffrey Greenwell began with a lead forwarded to St. Louis from
Los Angeles, where a state and federal task force was in the
process of dismantling Lost Boy, an online network of
pedophiles who traded photos and videos via the Internet.
Ultimately, the Greenwell investigation spun off into four
additional cases in four different states.
In early 2010, Captain John Foster, a detective with the Yell
County Sheriff's Department in northwest Arkansas, received a
package of photos prepared by Brian Mize, a forensic investigator
with the St. Louis Division of the FBI.
The images, which Mize had culled from the thousands he'd found
stored on hard drives and other media seized from Greenwell's
house, depicted various shots of four boys. Mize believed each of
the boys had been sexually molested by a man named Evan
Batton, a youth pastor at a Baptist church near the city of
Dardanelle.
Foster immediately recognized the face of one of the children: "a
cute little redheaded kid, wearing an army helmet," he recalls.
Later that same day, Foster drove to Batton's house armed with a
search warrant and accompanied by a team that included an agent
from the FBI's Little Rock Division. When Batton answered the
door, the lawmen could see that the pastor wasn't alone. There was
a little boy in the house — another face Foster had seen in Mize's
dossier.
Rather than face a jury trial, Batton agreed to plead guilty to one
felony count for the rape of a seven-year-old boy. Now 29, he
is serving a 30-year sentence in state prison. He did not respond
to two letters from Riverfront Times requesting comment for this
story.
Yell County Prosecuting Attorney Tom Tatum II says he has
chat-room transcripts in which Batton boasts to Greenwell about
setting up a webcam in his bedroom in order to record himself
having sex with boys.
"To have this guy in our back yard and not know it was shocking,"
says Tatum. "We were glad to get the tip and get rid of him."
During an interrogation session on the day he was arrested in 2009,
Greenwell revealed the name of a child pornographer whose
handiwork was widely shared on Lost Boy. Investigators in LA and
St. Louis knew of the man only by his online alias, "SpongeBob."
In late 2009 a federal grand jury in Utah reviewed evidence
that proved sufficient to indict Antonio Cardenas, a.k.a.
SpongeBob, who is in jail awaiting trial, having entered a plea of
not-guilty to seven counts of production and distribution of child
pornography and aggravated sexual abuse of a child.
Mize was able to identify two other child pornographers whose
images were part of Greenwell's massive stash. One remains at
large in a Midwestern state, according to the FBI. Investigators
tracked down the other man, an insurance manager in New
Hampshire, only to learn that he had committed suicide in
2008.
12/7/2011:
New York, Albany
New York Lawmakers Could Reform Child Abuse Laws
Similar to California Legislation
New York state lawmakers said the announcement on Wednesday
that a former Syracuse University coach will not face sex abuse
charges because the statute of limitations had run out could boost
efforts to reform state child abuse laws.
One proposal would provide for the five-year statute of limitations
to begin when victims turn 23, instead of age 18 as it now stands,
said New York State Assemblywoman Margaret Markey. She
introduced the proposal seven years ago after a constituent said he
had long ago been abused by a priest but nothing could be done
because of the statute of limitations. Her bill also would create a
one-year window, beginning when the law takes effect, for victims
to bring civil claims against alleged abusers for whom the statute
of limitations has passed. Civil suits allow alleged victims to seek
monetary damages but not prison time.
Since the Syracuse University scandal broke, Markey said her
colleagues have been asking more about her proposal, which she
said was modeled on similar legislation in California. Former
Syracuse University basketball coach Bernie Fine has been accused
by two men of fondling them as juveniles beginning as far back as
the 1980s.
Investigators believe the accusations are true but Fine cannot be
prosecuted under state law due to the statute of limitations, District
Attorney William Fitzpatrick said. Fine has said the accusations
are "patently false."
"We will be drawing attention to this because I see it as the only
way to help the victims of Syracuse and Brooklyn Poly Prep,"
Markey said, referring to claims that a football coach at the
Brooklyn private school molested dozens of boys over 25 years.
In 2005, a Poly Prep alumnus sued the school, but the case was
thrown out because of the statute of limitations. The coach
accused of molesting the boys, Philip Foglietta, died in 1998. Last
year, seven alumni filed a federal suit accusing the school of
covering up the abuse for years.
"People should be up in arms about this, but I don't feel the
rage," Markey said. "These victims deserve to be
compensated."
Legislators said there has been some opposition to the civil
window because it would allow anyone to bring a claim even if
they were abused many decades previously. A related issue is the
rights of the accused because, some argue, extending the statute of
limitations too far would make it impossible to present an adequate
defense.
The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that criminal statutes of
limitations cannot be changed retroactively but civil statutes can be
altered, which her bill would do, Markey said.
Reforms adopted in Delaware in 2007 eliminated the civil statute
of limitations on sexual abuse and allowed a two-year window for
civil suits by victims for whom the statute of limitations had
passed. Under the Delaware law, 14 men who said they were
sexually assaulted as children in the 1970s and 1980s announced
last week they reached a $7 million settlement with three Catholic
Church institutions that employed and supervised their predators.
In Pennsylvania, lawmakers said this week that in the wake of the
sexual abuse scandal at Penn State University they would propose
reforms to give victims more time to press civil claims. At Penn
State, former assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky, 67, faces 52
counts of sexually abusing ten young boys over a 15-year period.
He has denied he abused the boys.
In New York, another bill in the Assembly would change the law
so the five-year period begins when a crime is first reported to law
enforcement. Another bill would extend the statute of limitations
for sex offenses against minors for 30 years. Assemblyman J. Gary
Pretlow, who sponsored the 30-year proposal, said recently that the
Syracuse case would reinvigorate his push to get the bill passed
next year.
"Many times, people are too embarrassed to come forward," he
said. "If people do come forward later in life, the person who did
it should be punished."
New York state prosecutors said they would turn over the evidence
in the Syracuse case to federal authorities. There is no federal
statute of limitations on abuse of minors during the life of the
victim. But Steven Statsinger, assistant federal defender at Federal
Defenders of New York, said that federal prosecutors would have
to establish jurisdiction to bring a case. If the alleged abuse
occurred only in New York, for example, prosecutors may find it
hard to establish federal jurisdiction.
"In order for it to be a federal offense, there would have to be
something inter-state about it," said Statsinger.
12/7/2011:
PA, State College - 12/7/2011
Ex-Penn State Coach Arrested On New Abuse Charges
- UPDATE of 11/10/2011 article
Ex-Penn State coach Jerry Sandusky was arrested and arraigned
Wednesday on new sex abuse charges brought by two new
accusers, the state attorney general's office said. The charges were
brought after new accusers were questioned by a grand jury
following Sandusky's arrest last month. One alleged victim claims
he was assaulted after meeting Sandusky in 1997 and the other
claims he was assaulted in 2004.
Sandusky was already charged with 40 counts of child sex abuse
involving eight young boys over a 15-year span. He has denied
being a pedophile and has vowed to fight the case. In interviews
with NBC and The New York Times, he has said he showered and
horsed around with boys but never sexually abused them.
Like some of the other victims, the two new ones, dubbed Victims
9 and 10 by prosecutors, allegedly met Sandusky through The
Second Mile charity, which he founded in 1977.
"As in many of the other cases identified to date, the contact with
Sandusky allegedly fit a pattern of 'grooming' victims," Attorney
General Linda Kelly said in a statement. "Beginning with outings
to football games and gifts; they later included physical contact
that escalated to sexual assaults."
One of the new alleged victims, dubbed Victim 9 by prosecutors,
claims he was first assaulted in 2004, and the other, called Victim
10, told the grand jury he was assaulted after being referred to
Second Mile in 1997. The ninth accuser, currently 18, was 11 or
12 when he first met Sandusky in 2004. Sandusky took him to Penn
State football games and gave him gifts and money, and later
sexually assaulted him during overnight stays in a basement
bedroom in Sandusky's home, the grand jury said.
The accuser said that Sandusky forced the boy to perform oral sex
and attempted on at least 16 occasions to anally penetrate him,
sometimes successfully. "The victim testified that on at least one
occasion he screamed for help, knowing that Sandusky's wife was
upstairs, but no one ever came to help him," the grand jury report
said.
The 10th accuser told the grand jury he was referred to The Second
Mile in 1997, when he was 10 and experiencing problems at home.
He also attended Penn State games, spent time at Sandusky's
house, and was subjected to "wrestling sessions" in the basement
of the home that led to Sandusky performing oral sex on the boy,
authorities said. The accuser also detailed incidents at a pool on the
Penn State campus, and a time when Sandusky allegedly exposed
himself in a car and requested oral sex from the boy.
He was arrested by state police and agents of the Attorney
General's Office, and had a preliminary arraignment before Senior
Magisterial District Judge Robert E. Scott of Westmoreland
County. A preliminary hearing on the charges is set for Tuesday,
the same day his previous case is set for a hearing.
Sandusky had been charged with 40 counts of child sex abuse
involving eight young boys over a 15-year span.
11/18/2011:
New York, Syracuse
Assistant Coach Bernie Fine Under investigation
for Child Sexual Abuse
Longtime Syracuse University assistant coach Bernie Fine is the
subject of a police investigation into allegations that he molested
a team ball boy for more than a dozen years, starting in the
mid-1980s, according to an ESPN report. The alleged victim,
Bobby Davis, told ESPN that Fine began molesting him in 1983
just before Davis entered seventh grade. According to the report,
Davis says the abuse happened at Fine’s home, Syracuse basketball
facilities and on road trips, including the 1987 Final Four. Davis
spent six years as Syracuse’s ball boy. Fine is in his 35th season as
a Syracuse assistant to Jim Boeheim. He has been placed on
administrative leave.
Davis, now 39, says the abuse continued until he was 27 and
reported the abuse to Syracuse police in 2003, but detectives told
him the statute of limitations had expired and they would not
investigate. ESPN investigated the story in 2003, but decided not
to run the story because Davis was the only person willing to talk.
The Syracuse Post-Standard also investigated the allegations in
2003. The news is emerging now because another alleged victim
says he was sexually abused by Fine and is coming forward now
because of news coverage of the Jerry Sandusky sexual-abuse
scandal at Penn State, according to ESPN’s story.
According to the New York Penal Code, there is no statute of
limitations “for prosecuting first-degree rape, first-degree criminal
sexual act, or first-degree course of sexual conduct against a
child,” but the statute of limitations “for other sexual offenses
committed against a child under age 18 is five years after the
victim reaches age 18, or the offense is reported to a law
enforcement agency or statewide central register of child abuse and
maltreatment, whichever is earlier.”
Syracuse head coach Jim Boeheim released a statement in support
of Fine: ''This matter was fully investigated by the University in
2005 and it was determined that the allegations were unfounded.
I have known Bernie Fine for more than 40 years. I have never
seen or witnessed anything to suggest that he would [have] been
involved in any of the activities alleged. Had I seen or suspected
anything, I would have taken action. Bernie has my full support.''
In a statement by Syracuse University: “We understand that the
Syracuse City Police has now reopened the case, and Syracuse
University will cooperate fully. We are steadfastly committed to
ensuring that SU remains a safe place for every student”.
11/10/2011:
PA, Harrisburg
Paterno and President Fired in Penn State
Child Sexual Abuse Scandal
- UPDATE of 11/9/2011 article
Famed U.S. college football coach Joe Paterno and Grahm Spanier,
the president of Penn State University, were fired on Wed. in
fallout from a child-abuse scandal and cover-up involving a former
assistant coach and school officials. The move by the university’s
board of trustees thwarted an attempt by Paterno, 84 and one of the
most iconic names in American sports, to leave the team on his
own terms. It triggered protests on campus from students.
Penn State, its football program and Paterno were thrown into
turmoil on Saturday when charges were filed against long-time
assistant coach Jerry Sandusky. Sandusky, 67, is accused of
sexually abusing at least eight boys over more than a decade.
Assistant Coach, Mike McQueary, had reported to Paterno seeing
Sandusky sexually assaulting a young boy in the Penn State
showers. Paterno notified the athletic director, Tim Curley, and a
vice-president, Gary Schultz, who in turn notified Spanier.
Curley and Schultz have been charged with failing to report the
incident to authorities. Pennsylvania Attorney General Linda
Kelly has not ruled out charges against Spanier. Paterno is not a
target of the criminal investigation, but the state police
commissioner called his failure to contact police himself a lapse in
“moral responsibility”.
Effective immediately, Doctor (Graham) Spanier is no longer
president of the university," John Surma, vice chairman of trustees,
told a news conference. "Joe Paterno is no longer the head football
coach, effective immediately. These decisions were made after
careful deliberations," said Surma. "We don't yet know all the facts
and there are many details that are yet to be worked out." The
trustees will appoint a committee to investigate the
“circumstances” that resulted in the indictment of Sandusky and of
Curley and Schultz. The committee will be appointed Friday at the
board’s regular meeting, which Gov. Tom Corbett said he plans to
attend, and will examine “what failures occurred and who is
responsible and what measures are necessary to ensure that similar
mistakes aren’t made in the future”.
In Washington, the U.S. Department of Education said it has
launched an investigation into the conduct at Penn State, which
must disclose criminal offenses committed on campus each year.
"If these allegations of sexual abuse are true then this is a horrible
tragedy for those young boys," Education Secretary Arne Duncan
said in a statement. "If it turns out that some people at the school
knew of the abuse and did nothing or covered it up, that makes it
even worse."
11/9/2011:
Pennsylvania, Harrisburg
Penn State Coach Paterno to Retire Amid Scandal - UPDATE of 11/7/2011 article
Legendary Penn State football coach Joe Paterno says he’s retiring
at the end of this season, this in the wake of a child abuse scandal
involving his longtime assistant coach Jerry Sandusky.
Paterno has been questioned about how he acted when a graduate
assistant, Mike McQueary, reported the incident to him in 2002.
Paterno notified Penn State athletic director Tim Curley and vice
president Gary Schultz. Curley and Schultz have since been
charged with failing to report the incident to the authorities.
Paterno hasn't been accused of legal wrongdoing. But he has been
assailed, in what the state police commissioner called a lapse of
"moral responsibility," for not doing more to stop Sandusky, whose
lawyer says he is innocent.
The coach defended his decision to take the news to the athletic
director. Paterno said it was obvious that the graduate student,
since identified as McQueary, was "distraught," but said he was
not told about the "very specific actions" in the grand jury report.
After Paterno reported the incident to Curley, Sandusky was told
to stay away from the school, but critics say the coach should have
done more - try to identify and help the victim, for example, or
alert authorities.
"Here we are again," John Salveson, former president of the
Pennsylvania chapter of the Survivors Network of those Abused by
Priests, said earlier this week. "When an institution discovers abuse
of a kid, their first reaction was to protect the reputation of the
institution and the perpetrator."
11/7/2011:
PA, Harrisburg
Sex Abuse Scandal at Penn State Widens
Two Penn State officials surrendered Monday on charges that they
failed to report suspected child-sexual abuse by a former coach and
committed perjury in their related grand jury testimony. Senior
Vice President Gary Schultz and Athletic Director Tim Curley both
stepped down from their posts late Sunday, one day after the
charges were announced. The pair are accused of failing to alert
police to complaints that former assistant football coach Jerry
Sandusky had sexually abused eight boys over a 15-year period.
They are also charged with lying to a state grand jury investigating
the former defensive coordinator.
“Schultz, 62, and Curley, 57, are innocent and will seek to have the
charges dismissed”, their lawyers said. Curley's lawyer called the
case weak, while Schultz's lawyer said the men did what they were
supposed to do by informing their superiors of the accusations.
Earlier Monday, investigators encouraged anyone who would
accuse Sandusky of sexual assault to step forward and talk to
police. A graduate assistant coach, Mike McQuery, had reported
witnessing an assault by Sandusky on a young boy, in 2002.
Pennsylvania Attorney General Linda Kelly specifically asked that
the child reportedly assaulted by Sandusky call detectives about the
2002 encounter.
When asked if it was possible that there were more victims, she
said: "When you look at the totality of the circumstances and the
number of victims that we have, I don't think it would be beyond
the realm of possibility that there are other victims that exist here."
Kelly also said the university's longtime football coach, Joe
Paterno, is not a target of the investigation into how the school
handled the accusations. "But somebody has to question about
what I would consider the moral requirements for a human being
that knows of sexual things that are taking place with a child,"
Noonan said. "I think you have the moral responsibility, anyone.
Not whether you're a football coach or a university president or the
guy sweeping the building. I think you have a moral responsibility
to call us."
Paterno has called the criminal charges shocking and troubling.
"If this is true we were all fooled, along with scores of
professionals trained in such things, and we grieve for the victims
and their families," he said in a statement Sunday.
10/27/2011:
California, Los Angeles
State says 1,000 foster homes match sex-offender addresses
The addresses for more than 1,000 foster homes and group
homes in California matched addresses on the state sex offender
registry, according to a newly released audit.
State Auditor Elaine M. Howle said child welfare officials failed
to check the sex offender registry even after her office advised
them to do so in 2008. The auditor informed state regulators and
local child welfare agencies of the 1,000 sex offender hits in July.
According to the Sacramento Bee, about 600 of the highlighted
offenders were considered high risk. The matching addresses
involved both foster care facilities and homes, according to the
Sacramento Bee. So far, eight licenses have been revoked or
suspended and regulators issued 36 orders barring individuals from
licensed facilities.
According to the Fresno Bee, the investigation was spurred by the
killing of a young boy in the foster care system. The audit was
ordered earlier this year at the request of state Assemblyman Henry
Perea (D-Fresno). The audit was also intended to compile data on
deaths of children who were under the oversight of child
protective services.
According to SacBee, the locations of the sex offenders have not
been disclosed, but Sacramento, Fresno and Alameda counties
were all targeted for the audit.
Los Angeles County was also selected for investigation, according
to the LA Times, but the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
balked at subpoenas for information and hired outside lawyers to
fight the inquiry. The auditor's office has vowed to continue to
press the county for records and to issue a second report in the
coming months.
Oregon, Portland
Boy Scouts face more sex abuse claims in court
Cases in Oregon and Montana - UPDATE of 9/1/2010 article
Four Oregon men plan to sue the Boy Scouts of America on
Tuesday over childhood sexual abuse they say they suffered at
the hands of a pedophile knowingly appointed as their scoutmaster in the 1970s, their lawyer said. The lawsuits, to be
filed in Multnomah County Circuit Court in Portland, accuse
the national Boy Scouts of negligence and fraud in connection
with the repeated molestation of the men, then aged 12 to 15,
their lawyer, Kelly Clark, told Reuters. The suits are the latest
in a barrage of such claims facing the Boy Scouts,
headquartered in Texas, since the organization was found liable
and ordered to pay nearly $20 million in damages last year for
a pedophile case from the 1980s.
Clark and his co-counsel, Paul Mones, brought a separate case
against the Boy Scouts last week on behalf of five women who
claim they were sexually abused as girls by the leader of a coed
Scouting program in Montana during the 1970s. The Montana
suit and the impending cases in Oregon bring to at least 35 the
number of individuals who have lodged child sexual abuse
claims against the Boy Scouts of America in 11 states since
2007, Clark said.
The group cites new safeguards instituted during the past
decade, including tighter screening of its volunteers, though it
acknowledges that criminal background checks for existing
volunteers only became mandatory in 2008.
Clark said publicity from last year's trial in Portland prompted
hundreds of former Scouts to contact his law firm. He likened
the "domino effect" of that case to the tide of allegations
against Roman Catholic priests in the United States
triggered more than a decade ago by reports of clergy abuse
that surfaced in the Boston Archdiocese. "What these
institutions have in common is the sense that their mission is
important and that they can't afford to have their good works
sullied by what they consider isolated incidents," Clark said.
Last year's trial shed light on records the BSA kept on
suspected or confirmed sexual abuse by leaders and volunteers.
The jury was permitted to review 20,000 pages from what were
termed the "perversion files" or "ineligible volunteer files,"
dating from 1965 to 1985 before rendering a verdict. The
lawsuit claims the BSA was aware since the 1960's that
“scouting posed a danger to adolescent boys because
historically noticeable numbers of adult volunteers...were
discovered to be child molesters.” Those files show that
during the 20-year period, an average of nearly 60 leaders
or volunteers a year were discovered molesting children,
Clark said. The Boy Scouts dispute that figure, and the
organization is fighting to keep those documents from being
made public in a case awaiting a ruling by the Oregon Supreme
Court.
All four bringing suit in the new case claim they were
abused in the 1970s by then-scoutmaster Steven Terry Hill,
who was put in charge of their troop even though the Boy
Scouts learned he had been accused of molesting three other
boys while serving as a Scout leader in California, Clark
said. The plaintiffs also allege that the Boy Scouts organization
became aware that Hill was molesting boys in Portland's Troop
76 but did nothing to stop it, according to Clark. Hill was
acquitted in the late 1970s of sex abuse charges related to the
Boy Scouts in Portland. But he was convicted in 1991 on four
counts of sodomy and furnishing drugs and alcohol to a minor
stemming from an unrelated sex-abuse case involving a
17-year-old boy. He was released from prison in 2011 after
serving 20 years, Clark said. A deposition Hill gave while
incarcerated, and other corroborating evidence, suggests that
the California Scouts council arranged for him to be transferred
to Portland where, in 1976, he founded Troop 76, an elite group
of 76 scouts whose mission was “high adventure” activities like
river rafting and mountain climbing, Clark said.
James Hopper, a clinical psychology instructor at Harvard
Medical School, said it is not unusual for adults to wait many
years to reveal sexual abuse from their childhood, especially for
males, who may feel greater shame from their ordeals. "You
have stories of abuse emerging from the Catholic Church and
other institutions; now it's the Boy Scouts' turn," he said. Clark
said “You don’t have to be trained or anything. You just
show up and raise your hand and swear and you’re a
volunteer.” “So while the percent of volunteers in the Boy
Scouts who were abusers is, we believe, much smaller, the
numbers are relatively large, and the number of victims could
be the same or worse (than in the Catholic church)”.
8/3/2011:
Justice, Homeland Security announce
biggest online child-porn sting to date
The Departments of Justice and Homeland Security
announced the prosecution of 72 individuals for
participating in an online forum that encouraged
pedophilia and the exchange of child pornography on Wednesday. Attorney General Eric Holder and
Secretary of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano
announced that 52 of the 72 have been arrested as part
of Operation Delego, which began in December 2009.
The sting targeted almost 600 users of the online
pedophile site Dreamboard.
“The members of this criminal network shared a demented
dream to create the preeminent online community for the
promotion of child sexual exploitation," Holder said. "But
for the children they victimized, this was nothing short of
a nightmare." "The rules of Dreamboard were clear – and
they encouraged, and incentivized, the creation of child
pornography."According to the Justice Department,
Dreamboard members exchanged graphic images and
videos of adults molesting children, often violently, and
compiled a massive private library of images of child
sexual abuse. Justice officials detailed a number of
measures designed to reward particularly depraved
content. The group allegedly also encouraged the creation
of new images and videos of child sexual abuse by its
members; numerous Dreamboard members abused
children and then posted documentation on the board.
Those users were afforded the highest rank of "Super
VIP."
“As alleged in court documents, Dreamboard was a selfdescribed
global ‘community’ of pedophiles dedicated
to the relentless victimization and exploitation of
children 12 and under,” said assistant Attorney General
Lanny Breuer. “Using sophisticated methods to evade
detection by law enforcement, Dreamboard members
allegedly used the power and anonymity of the Internet to
motivate each other to commit their horrific acts of sexual
abuse of minors and trading in child pornography."
Operation Delgo involved cooperation between
Immigrations and Customs Enforcement, DOJ and dozens
of law enforcement agencies in countries including France,
Germany, Ecuador, Kenya, and Qatar. Thirteen of the 52
arrested have pleaded guilty while 20 remain at large and
known only by their online identities.
7/19/2011:
PA, Pennsylvania
Philadelphia Archbishop Steps Down Amid Scandal
Archdiocese has been under fire over accusations it concealed
sexual abuse of children.Cardinal Justin Rigali, whose leadership of the Philadelphia Roman Catholic archdiocese has been tainted by a continuing
scandal over sexual misconduct by priests, is set to retire Tuesday.
The archdiocese, the sixth largest in the United States with 1.5
million Catholics, has been under fire over accusations it concealed
the sexual abuse of children by priests to avoid a costly scandal.
The archdiocese website announced that Rigali, 76, is to be replaced
by Archbishop Charles Chaput, 66, who has been archbishop in Denver
since 1997.
The Catholic Church has been rocked by a series of sexual abuse
cover-up scandals in both Europe and the United States in recent years.
Rigali, archbishop in Philadelphia since 2003, has been struggling to
contain the pedophilia scandal in the wake of a Philadelphia grand jury
report issued at the beginning of this year. Three priests, a monsignor
and a church teacher were indicted as a result of the report.
"We would have assumed," said the grand jury in a report, "by the year
2011, after all the revelations both here and around the world, that the
church would not risk its youth by leaving them in the presence of priests
subject to substantial evidence of abuse. That is not the case." The grand
jury said that it found 37 such priests who have been kept in assignments
that exposed them to children. Of that number, 21 were suspended after the
report, and three more were placed on administrative leave.
7/12/2011:
Online Child Porn Bill being Presented
A bill that seeks to clamp down on online child pornography is
raising some alarms in the tech and privacy communities because of
a provision that would require Internet service providers to store
users' IP addresses for 18 months. The legislation, H.R. 1981,
spearheaded by House Judiciary Committee Chairman Lamar Smith
(R-Texas) and Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz (D-Fla.), would
require Internet providers and possibly other entities to retain
that information to aid law enforcement investigations of child
exploitation. The bill already has some notable support, namely
from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.
However, it also faces tough criticism from tech companies and
public interest groups, which believe the section on data retention is
too broad, threatens Web users' privacy and may not accomplish its
stated goal of cracking down on child pornography. Those two sides
may clash over the bill Tuesday, when Smith's committee holds its
first legislative hearing since the legislation was introduced.
Ahead of the hearing, Smith said the proposal already has bipartisan
support, as it seeks to "address what may be the fastest growing
crime in America."
7/11/2011:
Georgia, Atlanta
Georgia Sex Trafficking Law Goes into Effect
One of the nation's toughest crackdowns on human trafficking has taken effect in Georgia, striking a delicate balance between
tougher penalties for criminals and more treatment for victims
that advocates said could be a model for other states seeking to
fight the sex trade.
The legislation took effect this month after a four-year legislative
fight, overhauling the way Georgia treats people forced into
prostitution. It bars prosecutors from charging people with sex crimes
if the offense occurred while the person was a victim of trafficking. It
also tacks on tough new criminal penalties for human traffickers.
The dual approach helped appease both religious conservatives, who
argued the changes could effectively legalize prostitution, and
children's advocates, who said a safety valve was needed for victims
who were forced into the sex trade.
"This is America's dirty little secret, these are crimes the public
doesn't see, that the public doesn't want to believe exist; these are
hidden victims," said Ernie Allen of the National Center for Missing
and Exploited Children, who praised Georgia's new crackdown.
"Historically, what law enforcement has tended to do is to arrest the
kid," he said. "We are trying to ensure that they focus on the pimp
and the customer."
The legislation calls for a 25-year minimum sentence for those
convicted of using coercion to traffic someone under the age of 18,
and slaps a minimum sentence of five years on those who pay for sex
with a 16-year-old. People trying to have sex with someone even
younger face at least 10 years behind bars.
The measure includes protections that allow a prostituted child or
adult to avoid criminal charges if they can prove they were coerced
into it. Under the measure, coercion doesn't mean just physical abuse
but also financial harm, destruction of immigration documents and
drug use.
6/23/2011:
California, San Diego
Countywide Sex Offender Sweep
Sixty-one people were under investigation Thursday
following a sweep in which hundreds of law enforcement
officers fanned across San Diego County and contacted
more than 800 registered sex offenders to determine
if they were in compliance with the terms of their
release, authorities said. The sweep was carried out
early Wed. morning by 300 members of the San Diego
Sexual Assault Felony Enforcement Task Force.
David Collazo, Task Force Commander, said “We want sex
offenders in San Diego to know they are being actively
watched”. Our goal was to verify they are
complying with registration laws, and to identify any
illegal activity they might be engaged in.” He said the
vast majority of the sex offenders visited this week were
in compliance with the law and living at their registered
addresses. “That’s a good indicator that offenders in this
community know we take the registration laws very
seriously”, Collazo said. Besides the 61 individuals now under
investigation, an additional 14 were arrested for various
probation and parole violations, and one was taken into
custody for a suspected homicide. The searches
also turned up pornography, marijuana and drug paraphernalia,
along with normally legal items many sex offenders aren’t
allowed to possess, like laptop computers, digital media,
smart phones, alcohol and children’s clothing and toys.
There are about 4,000 registered sex offenders living
in San Diego County.
6/15/2011:
Australia
Australian Police Make Arrests After Online
Child Abuse Network Busted
Australian police have carried out a world-first bust on a sophisticated
online child abuse network, arresting 11 men in four states and rescuing
two abused children. Covert police operatives spent four months infiltrating
the network, secretly taking the place of those they arrested to allow them
to delve deeper into the group of men aged between 26 and 67 who were
sharing images and videos of the sexual abuse of children as young as four.
The organization, which used complex "peer-to-peer" software rather than a
traditional central server to make it harder for law enforcement agencies to
uncover the material, is the first of its kind closed down by the multinational
Virtual Global Task force, chaired by the Australian Federal Police.
The men, many of whom had direct access to children on a daily basis, included a teacher, IT specialist, security worker and a convicted sex offender, as well
as a farmer. Two young children were removed from the custody of a 26-year-old
NSW man, whose identity was suppressed, and he was charged with having sexual
intercourse with a child under 10. Parents and students at the exclusive King's School were in shock after it was revealed long-term preparatory school teacher Gregory
John Coupland, 40, from Forestville in Sydney's northern beaches, was among the men.
Coupland, who had taught at the school for 12 years and was master in charge
of snow sports, taking groups of primary-aged children on regular multi-day skiing trips,
was also running a scout troop until he was charged last month with using a carriage
service to access child pornography, using a carriage service to transmit child pornography
and possessing child abuse material.
King's Preparatory School head Keith Dallywater said that the news had come
"as a significant shock" but confirmed that no students had been harmed in any way.
Six of the men were from NSW, three from Victoria, and one each from Queensland and
South Australia. AFP manager of hi-tech investigations Commander Grant Edwards said, while
Operation Danton had been a success, police were aware of other child abuse networks using the
same file sharing service and forensic searches were ongoing.
"The images accessed are of real children being abused and it's a shocking thing,"
Commander Edwards said.
6/15/2011:
New York, Manhattan
Arrest of 26 in Network that traded child
rape videos, images
Manhattan district attorney, Cyrus Vance, Jr.,
announced Tues. that his office had filed charges
against 26 individuals related to the possession of
images or videos showing the sexual abuse of children.
“These images...are babies, toddlers, and children being
brutally raped, sexually assaulted and exploited by
adults on camera.”
The New York Times reports that “the charges were a
result of a five-month investigation conducted by the
district attorney’s office and the United States Immigration
and Customs Enforcement office. According to the New
York Daily News, the defendants, ages ranging from 18 to
63, included Steven Roman, who worked in a children’s
shoe store, Miguel Caraballo, who was once a dishwasher
at Manhattan’s Alice’s Tea Cup (a Lewis Carroll-themed
teahouse catering to kids), substitute teacher Joshua Ruiz,
and Moshe Gerstein, a corporate attorney.
“The 26 defendants in these cases traded videos and still
images of child sexual assault the way others traded
baseball cards,” Vance stated, “using peer to peer technology,
they acted as curators of their collection.”
According to the Times, officials from the DA’s office said they
would hand over the images collected as part of the investigation
to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, an
organization in Virginia that keeps a database of seized material
as part of its Child Victim Identification Program.
6/14/2011:
California, San Diego
San Diego County takes steps to fight
sex trafficking
The San Diego County Board of Supervisors voted
5-0 Tuesday to establish a committee of local law
enforcement agencies to battle human trafficking
and the sexual exploitation of youth. The San Diego
Regional Human Trafficking and Commercial Sexual
Exploitation of Children Advisory Council will operate similarly to other regional groups that combat
auto theft, gangs and drugs. Area law enforcement
officials have said recently that while crime is going
down in the region, sexual exploitation of teenagers
is increasing, and frequently involves gang members
impressing girls into prostitution in areas like Spring
Valley.
“I can tell you this is a very real problem, not just in
East County, but around the state”, said Hank Turner of
the Deputy Sheriff’s Association. The issue is ignored
at the state level, and San Diego is one of the few counties
to address the problem, Turner said.
6/14/2011:
Massachusetts, Milford
Mass. Man Charged in Amsterdam Sex Case
A Massachusetts man whose case led to the discovery of a massive
child sex abuse case in the Netherlands has been charged with
distributing child pornography, according to court documents.
Robert Diduca, 47, was a member of an online forum for those
with a sexual interest in children. He came to the attention of law
enforcement last year when he sent a pornographic image of a child
via e-mail to investigators of Homeland Security Investigations
(HSI), who alerted Massachusetts State Police.
Diduca was arrested at his home in Milford, a town in Worcester
County of Massachusetts, in early November 2010. During a
search of his computer storage devices, investigators discovered
some 10,000 images and videos of young children engaged in
sexual acts. One of the images recovered from his computer
showed an adult man sexually abusing a two-year-old boy.
Investigators determined that the photos and videos did not appear
to have been made in the United States and shared an edited image
on Interpol's secure system for international law enforcement
officials in order to help identify the victim.
As a result, Dutch police soon recognized the material was of
Dutch origin and requested additional photos to help in the
investigation. An edited photo of the victim was eventually shown
on Dutch television on December 7 after which someone
recognized the child and called police.
Hours later, police in the Netherlands arrested 27-year-old Robert
Mikelsons who confessed to sexually abusing dozens of young
children while being employed at two Amsterdam nurseries between February 2007 and January 2010. He also offered his
services through several websites. Mikelsons is believed to have abused at least 85 young children.
Diduca, who remains in custody, previously pled not guilty to
similar charges. If found guilty, he faces at least 5 years and up to
20 years in prison, followed by up to lifetime supervised release
and a $250,000 fine.
6/8/2011:
Canada, New Brunswick
New Brunswick Record Child Porn Bust
Douglas Hugh Stewart, 51, from Moncton, pleaded
guilty to possessing millions of images seized in
March. Const. Jean-Marc Pare, of the RCMP Internet
Child Exploitation Unit in Fredericton, said
police in Canada have never seen anything quite
like it. Other arrests are expected. The ongoing
investigation into peer-to-peer computer file sharing
of child sexual abuse images in the province– known
as Operation J Treasures– began in November 2010.
“There have been a few out west that numbered over
3 million. We don’t know the exact number of ours
yet, but we know we’ll be well over five million.”
Pare said they’re dealing with a subculture of people
who collect these images like other collect hockey cards.
He said the images have been sent to the national RCMP
unit in Ottawa, which could lead to the identification of
more victims and possibly more offenders. “But those
offenders are becoming more sophisticated, he said, both
in methods of storing the images and luring victims”.
4/30/2011:
Utah
Utah authorities arrest dozens in child porn
investigation
After 114 sex crime investigations, 124 computer seizures,
more than 36 million images, thousands of overtime hours
and 39 arrests, Utah’s Internet crime investigators on Thurs.
offered a flat proclamation for their month-long, statewide child
pornography bust. Farnsworth said some of the 114 suspects
are accused of filming or photographing their own illegal sex acts
with children as young as toddlers. Investigators will not know how
many Utah children were victims in the cases until they review the
images seized – the total number is estimated in excess of 36 million,
according to figures provided by the attorney general’s office.
3/17/2011:
Thailand, Pattaya
The Pattaya Link to Worldwide Child Sexual Abuse
Foreign child sex abusers in Pattaya, some of whom
were repeatedly released by the police or courts, were
targeted in “Operation Rescue” which centered on a website
called “Boy Lover”. The website has 70,000 members,
dozens of whom were in Thailand or frequent visitors to
the country. More arrests are expected in the operation in
which 670 pedophile suspects have been targeted worldwide.
Those arrested include scout leaders, football coaches, and
in Britain, even a police officer, was among the 100 arrested.
In The Hague, Holland, where the “Boy Lover” website is
based, police say they had arrested 184 people and taken 230
children out of danger. Of the total, 240 suspects aged
between 17 and 82 were in Britain where 121 arrests were
made and 60 children rescued from abusers.
The Operation Rescue was led by investigators at the Child
Exploitation and Online Protection Centre (CEOP). Boy Lover
operated in several languages across 11 sub-domains worldwide.
3/16/2011:
United Kingdom
World’s Largest Pedophile Ring Uncovered
An internet pedophile ring with up to 70,000
members- thought to be the largest yet discovered,
has been uncovered by police. Rob Wainright,
Director of Europol, The European police agency,
said it's "probably the largest pedophile
network in the world". Europol said in a statement
that "Operation Rescue" had identified 670 suspects
and that 230 abused children in 30 countries had
been taken to safety. More children are expected
to be found. Europol said that so far 184 people
had been arrested, which include teachers, police
officers, scout leaders, and a youth camp worker suspected of abusing some 100 children over five
years.
The website was shut down after a 3-year
investigation. It had operated from a server
based in the Netherlands, and had had up to 70,000
members worldwide. Law enforcement authorities
from 13 countries, including the U.S., were involved
in the case. Europol analysts had cracked the security
features of a key computer server at the center of the
network which uncovered the identities of suspected
child sex offenders. There will be more arrests as
investigations continue.
12/20/2010:
Florida, St. Petersburg
Author of Pedophilia How-to Book Arrested
Florida Sheriff arrested a Colorado man, Phillip Ray Greaves II,
who wrote a guide for pedophiles, on obscenity charges. Polk
Sheriff Grady Judd says his office was able to arrest Greaves on
Florida Obscenity charges because he sold and mailed his book,
"The Pedophile's Guide to Love and Pleasure: a Child Lover's
Code of Conduct", to Polk deputies. The self-published book
was briefly for sale on Amazon, but probably due to public
outcry, it was later removed from the website.
Basically, the main issue in question is if he committed a crime.
It's not a crime in Colorado, but it is a crime in Florida. Another
question being raised is the right to free speech. But Sheriff Judd,
known in Florida as a crusader against child predators, said
"What's wrong with a society that has gotten to the point that we
can't arrest child pornographers and child molesters who write a
book about how to rape a child? If we can get jurisdiction... we're
coming after you. There's nothing in the world more important
than our children."
12/8/2010:
Canada, Toronto
Project Sanctuary Rescues 25 Children from Child Sexual Abuse
Dubbed Project Sanctuary, the investigation began in
Nov. 2009, bringing together the U.S. Dept. of Homeland
Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE),
Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), 13 Canadian
police services, and international police services and officers
from the Child Exploitation Section of the Toronto Police
Services Sex Crimes Unit.
For a year undercover officers went deep into the worldwide
network of men who were allegedly trading child sexual
abuse images and videos and, in some cases, creating these
images by abusing children. That undercover operation has
netted the arrest of 57 men world-wide with 25 of them from
Canada. Twelve of the 25 children rescued as a result of Project Sanctuary are from Canada.
“This operation is an excellent example of what can be
accomplished through cooperative police work between
the U.S. and Canada. Nothing is more important than our
combined efforts to prevent the exploitation of our children,”
said Tom Blanchard, ICE HSI Attache in Canada.
11/19/2010:
San Diego
Surprise Visits to Registered Sex Offenders
Hundreds of convicted sex offenders have been
arrested after a four day sweep across California
including dozens in San Diego County, according
to state parole agents.
Operation Safe Playgrounds began on Monday.
State parole agents, along with local law enforcement,
conducted compliance checks on registered sex
offenders. "The short message is, if you're a sex
offender and you are not in compliance in any way,
we are going to track you down and get you back in
compliance", said parole agent Sean Torphy of the
California Parolee Apprehension Team.
On Friday, state parole officials will hold a press
conference to release the finale number of arrests for
California.
11/18/2010:
Washington
FBI Shuts Down U.S. Child Slavery Ring
More than five dozen child prostitutes have been found in
the last three days as part of a nationwide crackdown on the
sexual exploitation of children. An FBI spokesman said 69
children were removed from prostitution and 99 suspected pimps were arrested in 40 cities across 30 states and the
District of Columbia. All the children found in the last three
days have been placed into protective custody or returned to
their families.
The children were found during Operation Cross Country V,
a three-day roundup targeting child traffickers and pimps.
The largest group of child prostitutes, 24, was found in and
around Seattle, according to the FBI. An FBI director said
the children found ranged in age from 12 to 17. Authorities
are working with the National Center for Missing and Exploited
Children to confirm their identities. Since 2003, when the FBI
and the Justice Dept. launched the Innocence Lost National
Initiative, about 1,250 child prostitutes have been located and
removed from prostitution.
10/25/2010:
California, San Diego
San Diego Diocese Sex Abuse Cases:
Lawyers Release 10,000 Unsealed Documents
After a three-year legal battle, nearly 10,000 pages of
previously sealed Catholic church documents have been
made public and showed that the Diocese of San Diego long
knew about abusive priests, some of whom were shuffled
from parish to parish despite credible complaints against them.
Attorneys for 144 people claiming sex abuse made the papers
public Oct. 24. The records are from the personnel files of 48 priests, who were either credibly accused or convicted of
sexual abuse, or were named in a civil lawsuit. They include a
decades-old case in which a priest under police investigation
was allowed to leave the U.S. after the diocese intervened.
The plaintiffs settled with the diocese in 2007 for nearly $200
million, but the agreement stipulated that an independent judge
would review the priest’s sealed personnel records and determine
what could be made public.
At least one of the priests, Gustavo Benson, is still in active
ministry in Ensenada, Mexico.
The release of records is the biggest so far in a U.S. church case,
said Terry McKierman, founder of the website Bishop Accountability.org Lawyers for plaintiffs have been trying to get similar internal church
documents from the Archdiocese of Los Angeles for years, but have
not had success. That diocese settled with more than 500 plaintiffs in 2007 for a record-breaking $660 million in a settlement agreement
that also called for the disclosure of priests files. The only other
release of church files in California came after a 2005 settlement
between plaintiffs and the Diocese of Orange. About 4,000 pages
were made public.
9/9/2010:
California, San Diego
Chelsea’s Law signed into Law
Convicted child molesters in California now
face life in prison after Gov. Schwarzenegger
signed "Chelsea's Law" Thursday. The measure,
named for slain Poway High School senior
Chelsea King, calls for mandatory life sentences
without parole for violent sex crimes against
children. It also tightens sex offense parole
guidelines and requires lifelong tracking of
certain sex offenders. The state Senate passed
the law in a unanimous vote.
8/31/10:
Chelsea’s Law Passes
California, Sacramento
Chelsea’s Law unanimously passed the Assembly on Monday.
Overcoming unexpected delays, Chelsea’s Law now goes to Gov.
Schwarznegger, who has committed to signing the bill. Assembly
Bill 1844 is designed to crackdown on sex offenders, including
longer sentences and tougher parole conditions as well as improved
testing and treatment to prevent future crimes.
The legislation is named after Poway teenager Chelsea King. She
was raped and murdered in February by John Gardner. Gardner
pleaded guilty to the crime, and also confessed to raping and killing
14-year-old Amber Dubois of Escondido in 2009. He is serving
two life sentences with out the possibility of parole.
Donalda Shepardson, the Founder and
President of CSH was interviewed on KRTM radio.
Interview with:
Donalda Shepardson
Click play button to listen to the interview. (15min.)
KRTM
88.9 FM
Program:
"Community Insight"
Host:
Kelly Thomas
Air Date:
02/24/07 Sat.
10/1/06:
CSH is looking for volunteers. Join
Creating Safer Havens’ Volunteers, the Team that Makes
a Difference in the Protection of Children and
Child Abuse Prevention. Please click
here to find out more about Volunteer Opportunity.